The Decemberists’ As It Ever Was, So It Will Be Again: A Return to Form
The Decemberists’ latest release, As It Ever Was, So It Will Be Again, marks a triumphant return to their indie-folk roots. The double LP showcases the Portland-based band’s talent for crafting narrative-driven songs while also pushing the boundaries of their sonic palette. This album is a celebration of the band’s 20-year journey, blending nostalgic ballads with experimental sounds, proving that The Decemberists can evolve while maintaining the essence that has endeared them to fans for two decades.
A Journey Through the Band’s Musical History
The album is structured in a way that reflects the band’s career trajectory, with each track serving as a nod to different phases of their sound. From the folksy ballads that defined their earlier albums like Castaways and Cutouts to the more expansive, orchestral arrangements of The Hazards of Love, As It Ever Was, So It Will Be Again provides a cohesive narrative that honors their musical evolution. The album’s storytelling approach remains at the forefront, with lead singer Colin Meloy’s lyrical genius weaving tales that evoke both personal and universal themes.
Blending Nostalgia with Sonic Experimentation
While much of the album feels like a nostalgic return to the band’s folk roots, The Decemberists continue to experiment with their sound. Tracks like “The Unseen Road” and “Persephone’s Garden” push the boundaries of indie-folk, incorporating lush orchestration, unconventional time signatures, and complex harmonies. These sonic experiments give the album a fresh, modern feel while staying true to the band’s storytelling tradition. The Decemberists have always been known for their ambition, and this album is no exception, balancing the old with the new.
Folksy Ballads That Tug at the Heartstrings
Longtime fans of The Decemberists will appreciate the more traditional, folksy ballads that make up a significant portion of the album. Songs like “Elder’s Lament” and “Wind and Ash” are deeply reflective and filled with the poetic lyricism that has defined Meloy’s songwriting since the band’s inception. These tracks are reminiscent of early Decemberists, offering simple acoustic arrangements that allow the lyrics to take center stage. The themes of loss, nostalgia, and reflection resonate throughout, making these ballads some of the most emotionally impactful songs on the album.
A Cohesive Narrative of 20 Years in Music
As It Ever Was, So It Will Be Again feels like more than just a collection of songs—it’s a cohesive narrative that traces the band’s 20-year history. Each side of the double LP acts as a chapter in their story, with the final tracks providing a sense of closure and resolution. The band’s ability to reflect on their past while continuing to innovate is what makes this album one of their best releases to date. It’s a celebration of their legacy and a testament to their relevance in the ever-evolving indie-folk genre.
Critical Acclaim and Fan Reception
The album has already garnered critical acclaim for its blend of nostalgic folk and ambitious experimentation. Fans have praised The Decemberists for staying true to their roots while also embracing growth and change. Many critics have noted that the album feels like a culmination of the band’s 20-year career, delivering both the comfort of familiarity and the excitement of new creative directions. For both longtime fans and newcomers, As It Ever Was, So It Will Be Again stands as a defining moment in The Decemberists’ discography.
In conclusion, As It Ever Was, So It Will Be Again solidifies The Decemberists’ place in indie-folk history, offering a masterful blend of nostalgia and innovation. The album not only celebrates the band’s past but also looks forward, ensuring that their storytelling and musical experimentation will continue to inspire fans for years to come.
